Dividing Lines

Pastor Emeritus Larry Peters has written an interesting piece attempting to identify the true dividing line between orthodox and heterodox churches and church bodies. He notes that while most assume that bibliology is key (think matters of inerrancy and infallibility), but he wonders if this is truly the case since there are groups with a high view of Scripture but a low view of the means of grace. Indeed, this does not make since. Affirmation of Scripture should lead to an affirmation of the Sacraments. Consider the following:

We believe that Scripture is itself sacramental—it speaks and in its speaking things happen. Hearts are warmed to faith and sins are forgiven and water bubbles with life and bread and wine actually become the flesh and blood of Jesus. This sacramental reality flows naturally from the Scriptures as living voice. We say this not to confine God to something alien to Him but precisely because this is how God has said He works.

And in the next paragraph he compares conservative Lutherans with conservative Baptists and concludes:

The reality is that [Baptists] do not speak the language of Scripture at all. The truth they seek to preserve is a testament or record to factual events of the past and is not a living voice that works through the Word. How can we say we have more in common with conservative Protestants than sacramental churches? The sinner's prayer and baptismal regeneration do not complement each other but work against each other. One group preserves the historicity of Scripture and its unconditional truth but then ignores what that Word says to invent a means of grace called the sinner's prayer. Where in Scripture or in the history of Christendom prior to the Reformation any sense in which God requires a decision from us or uses such a prayer in order to come to us and make His home in us? What ever happened to faith comes by hearing the Word of God?

While the piece uses Lutheran denomination (LC-MS) in opposition Baptist, this divide is important to understand in order to recognize if we are rightly positioned in relation to Scripture and the Sacraments. It is well worth a read.